Mulcare Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance

by

Mulcare Insurance Agency: Allstate Insurance — Wheaton, IL

Overview

What They Do / Products Offered

Mulcare Insurance Agency is an Allstate agency that offers a full suite of insurance products. Key offerings include:

They custom tailor policies to individual/family needs, aiming to balance protection of assets with a budget-friendly approach. Allstate Agents

Team & Agency Culture

  • Owners: Casey Mulcare (Agency Owner / Personal Financial Representative) and Amy Mulcare (Office Manager) opened the agency in 2010. Allstate Agents+1
  • Casey has previous experience working in various corporate positions at Allstate (13 years) which gives him insight into both sales and claims / operations side. Allstate Agents
  • Amy also worked in Allstate Home Office for about 8 years before focusing on running the agency. Allstate Agents
  • The staff includes several insurance consultants and customer service representatives (e.g. Samantha Dutcher, Aleta Fox, Matt Shebik, Jack Beverley, etc.) who handle customer service, policy consultation, claims assistance, etc. Allstate Agents
  • They emphasize personal, relationship-based service. Agents aim to be responsive, warm, helping customers understand options, not just selling a standard package. Allstate Agents+1

Community Involvement & Reputation

  • They are active locally: supporting the Wheaton Chamber of Commerce, Glen Ellyn Children’s Resource Center, Wheaton Lions Club, local schools, food banks, and local charity events. Allstate Agents+1
  • On Nextdoor, Yelp, and other local review sites, customers often praise them for friendly service, being helpful, clear communication. nextdoor.com+2MapQuest+2
  • BBB listing shows the business has been in operation since ~2010; it is not accredited by BBB, though it has a BBB profile. Better Business Bureau

Strengths

  • Personalized service: Multiple sources say that Mulcare prides itself on customer care, being attentive, taking time to explain coverage, etc. Allstate Agents+1
  • Range of insurance offerings: They provide many lines: auto, home, life, business, etc., which means customers can bundle and deal with fewer agents. Allstate Agents
  • Local roots / experienced owners: Founders have prior experience in Allstate’s organization, which helps in understanding both the insurer side and client expectations. Allstate Agents+1
  • Community engagement: Being visible in the community tends to build trust. Their involvement in local nonprofit/charity work enhances goodwill. Wheaton Chamber of Commerce+1

Weaknesses / Things to Consider

  • BBB Accreditation Status: They are not accredited by BBB, which may matter for some customers who use that as a trust indicator. Better Business Bureau
  • Premiums / Rate Increases: Some customer feedback suggests that in certain cases, premiums have increased significantly over a few years, even without claims. While this isn’t unique to this agency, it seems to be a concern among some clients. nextdoor.com
  • Comparisons / Discounts: Some feedback indicates customers feel the agency could do more to find ways to reduce premiums, for example via discounts or adjusting coverages. MapQuest+1
  • Limited geographic coverage: While servicing IL, WI, and IN, the agency is localized; if someone moves out of these states, continuity might be lost. (This may be obvious)

Who Might This Agency Be Good For

Mulcare Insurance Agency seems well suited to:

  • Individuals or families in Illinois, Wisconsin, or Indiana looking for a local, personal insurance agent rather than purely online/large-call center service.
  • People who want to bundle multiple insurance products (auto, home, life etc.) under one agent for easier management.
  • Those who value clarity, assistance in choosing coverages, and expect ongoing customer service—help with claims, policy reviews, etc.
  • People who want to support a local agency that is involved in the community.

Pricing & Value

  • Specific premium rates aren’t public, but thanks to the Allstate framework, there are various discounts, coverage options, and bundling possibilities. The agency seems to be competitive in local market based on customer testimonials (some say they switched from another insurer and got better coverage or rates). MapQuest
  • However, as with many insurance businesses, value depends heavily on individual factors: risk profile, credit score, location (risk of storms, theft, etc.), type & age of home/car, claims history, etc.

Summary

Mulcare Insurance Agency is a well-established, full-line Allstate agency in Wheaton, IL founded in 2010 by Casey & Amy Mulcare. It emphasizes personalized customer service, offers a wide range of insurance products, and is active in its community. Reviews tend to be positive, especially regarding helpfulness and responsiveness. As with any insurance agency, some customers report premium increases over time, so it’s wise to review your policy regularly, ask about possible discounts, and compare with other insurers to ensure good value.

Leave a Comment